The conference room at 9am. I watch my voice drop half an octave, my posture straighten, my laugh become more measured. By lunch with college friends, I'm someone else entirely... looser, funnier, but still carefully curated. Then dinner with my family: another version, pleasant and unthreatening. Later, scrolling Instagram: the polished, aspirational me emerges for the algorithm.
Four different rooms. Four different people. All me, supposedly.
I built a life everyone admired and then realized no one could actually find me inside it.
The Contract Nobody Signed But Everyone Knows
There's an unspoken agreement many gay men make early: "I'll be agreeable, high-functioning, and low-friction so you'll keep me safe." We call it adaptability. Resilience. Social skills.
It's actually a survival contract.
The Nice Gay Contract goes like this:
Be charming but not threatening. Successful but not intimidating. Present but not too much. Funny but not cutting. Sexual but sanitized. Available but not needy. Be the guest everyone wants at dinner parties and the employee who never rocks the boat.
The reward? Acceptance. Inclusion. Safety.
The fine print? Each polite "yes" sends an invoice to your nervous system. And that bill comes due.
Over-adaptation isn't resilience. It's self-erasure that gets rewarded until it ruins your nervous system and your relationships.
How We Learned the House Rules
The contract starts early. Gay boys learn to read rooms like meteorologists track storms, scanning for shifts in temperature, changes in pressure, the first whisper of danger.
School teaches us the basics: Be impressive enough to avoid being a target. Entertaining enough to be included. Careful enough to stay invisible when it matters. We master the art of being remarkable and unremarkable simultaneously.
Families refine the terms: Don't be too much. Too loud. Too emotional. Too gay. Learn to translate yourself into languages everyone else can understand without getting uncomfortable.
Workplaces add professional polish: "Culture fit" becomes code for "won't make waves." The promotion goes to the guy who makes everyone feel good about themselves, never the one who challenges or disrupts.
Even queer spaces have membership requirements: Be body-positive but photogenic. Politically aware but not exhausting. Sexually liberated but not messy. The community that was supposed to be refuge becomes another stage requiring performance.
Your shoulders live in a permanent slight hunch, braced for the next adjustment. Your throat holds a dozen unfinished sentences. The ones that felt too honest, too complicated, too you.
Where It Gets Rewarded
Corporate Ladders: "He's so easy to work with." "Never creates drama." "Such a team player." The Nice Gay climbs steadily because he never makes anyone examine their assumptions or feel uncomfortable about their jokes.
Social Media Algorithms: Controversy gets hidden. Agreeability gets amplified. The polished, palatable version of your life gets thousands of hearts while your actual struggles disappear into the digital void.
Gay Social Scripts: Be fun but not needy. Hot but not competitive. Successful but not threatening. The community rewards men who enhance everyone else's experience while demanding nothing for themselves.
The praise feels good. Necessary, even. Until you realize approval isn't love. It's credit. And credit has terms.
The Invoice
The Intimacy Tax: When you're always adapting, you become unfindable. Closeness can't attach to a moving target. Partners fall in love with your performance, then wonder why sex feels distant, why conversations stay on the surface, why you seem to disappear during the moments that should bring you closer.
The Desire Drain: Eroticism requires friction, surprise, the sharp edges of personality. Over-adaptation sandpapers everything smooth. You wonder why you feel detached during sex, why fantasies feel safer than presence, why arousal feels complicated when everything else in your life looks so simple.
The Loneliness of Being Liked: You're invited everywhere, complimented constantly, the person everyone wants at their table. Yet nobody sees you. The version they love is two degrees away from who you actually are. You're surrounded by people who adore a fiction.
Boundary Decay: Years of "sure" and "of course" and "no problem" erode your ability to know what you actually want. When someone asks what you'd prefer, the question feels foreign. Your desires atrophied from disuse.
Resentment Explosions: The bill comes due suddenly. A small request triggers massive irritation. You snap at the wrong person over the wrong thing because you've been swallowing the right responses for months.
Being agreeable was the down payment. Your authentic self became the mortgage.
The Myth of Healthy Adaptation
Here's what nobody tells you: there's a difference between healthy adaptation and self-erasure.
Healthy adaptation says: "I'll adjust my approach while keeping my core intact." Self-erasure says: "I'll become whatever you need me to be."
Resilience includes the capacity for friction. It means your system can handle conflict, disappointment, the discomfort of being seen as you actually are. Over-adaptation eliminates friction entirely, which looks peaceful until you realize you've also eliminated intimacy, desire, and truth.
Friction is how authenticity gets traction.
The Assimilation Hangover
You know that bone-deep exhaustion after social events where you performed flawlessly? That's not introversion. That's your nervous system processing the energy it took to maintain the contract.
I call it Assimilation Hangover; the emotional crash after extended periods of being "on brand" for other people. Your body metabolizing the distance between who you were and who you performed. The cellular cost of translation.
Some days you wake up and can't remember what you actually think about anything. Your opinions feel borrowed. Your preferences seem negotiable. You've been so busy being the right version of yourself that the original got lost in translation.
The Cost of Being Easy to Love
"You're so easy to be around," they say. And you smile because it sounds like a compliment.
But easy love isn't deep love. Frictionless connection isn't transformative connection. When you remove all the sharp edges, you also remove the possibility of being truly known.
The people who love your adapted self aren't lying. But they're not loving you. They're loving your customer service representative. The version trained to anticipate needs, smooth conflicts, make everyone comfortable.
Real intimacy requires the risk of being too much. Of saying the thing that might create distance. Of wanting something specific and being willing to be disappointed if you can't have it.
Why Support Matters More Than Willpower
You can't willpower your way out of a contract you signed under duress. The Nice Gay Contract was a survival strategy that worked... until it didn't. Unlearning it requires more than deciding to "be more authentic."
De-adaptation is relational work. The fear it triggers (if I stop smoothing, I'll be rejected) is relational fear. Trying to heal it alone confirms the very isolation that created the need for the contract in the first place.
My work helps gay men recognize where the contract serves and where it suffocates. Not to blow up your life, but to learn the difference between strategic adaptation and reflexive self-erasure.
Practicing friction as intimacy. Saying no as a form of attachment. Learning that healthy relationships can handle your actual personality, not just your polished version.
An Invitation, Not Instructions
If your life looks enviable but feels anesthetized, you're likely not broken. You're over-adapted. If success feels hollow and praise feels empty, your nervous system might be trying to tell you something important…
I don't want your applause if it costs me my outline.
Maybe the goal isn't to be loved by everyone. Maybe it's to be known by someone. Starting with yourself.
Until next week 💙
Gino
P.S. If you enjoyed this newsletter, please tap the Like button below. ❤️ It really does help.
If you'd like to read more, here are some related letters to this one:
The Gay Loneliness No One Wants to Talk About
I notice an unopened tissue box sitting next to him, a quiet witness. Men don't cry in their first sessions anymore. They've learned to describe devastation with dry eyes and steady voices. On my laptop screen is the kind of man Instagram insists should have it all… successful, photogenic, perfectly curated, and here he i…
Thank you for sharing 🙏
The Art of being remarkable and unremarkable at the same time. Visible and invisible. Code switching and adapting. It is exhausting.
Our very own community does not exactly reward authenticity and diversity.